Heenwedstrijd 3-3
Toeschouwers: 7.450.
Scheidsrechter: Dean Whitestone.
Scoreverloop:
St. James Park Exeter
Carlisle United F.C.06-05-2017 Exeter City F.C. vs Carlisle United F.C.
22-04-2017 Exeter City F.C. vs Morecambe F.C.
Exeter City F.C. 
3 vs 1 
Morecambe F.C.
3 vs 1 
Morecambe F.C.14-04-2017 Exeter City F.C. vs Barnet F.C.
Exeter City F.C. 2 vs 1 
Barnet F.C.
2 vs 1 
Barnet F.C.08-04-2017 Exeter City F.C. vs Newport County A.F.C.
Newport County A.F.C.25-03-2017 Exeter City F.C. vs Yeovil Town F.C.
Exeter City F.C. 3 vs 3 
Yeovil Town F.C.
3 vs 3 
Yeovil Town F.C.14-03-2017 Exeter City F.C. vs Cheltenham Town F.C.
Cheltenham Town F.C.11-03-2017 Exeter City F.C. vs Accrington Stanley F.C.
Accrington Stanley F.C.25-02-2017 Exeter City F.C. vs Blackpool F.C.
Exeter City F.C. 2 vs 2 Blackpool F.C.
2 vs 2 
Blackpool F.C.18-02-2017 Exeter City F.C. vs Stevenage F.C.
Exeter City F.C. 1 vs 1 
Stevenage F.C.
1 vs 1 
Stevenage F.C.